Buyer’s checklist · For shippers evaluating brokers

Questions to ask an AI freight broker before you tender a load

AI labels alone do not tell a shipper how a brokerage will handle a load. The useful question is not whether a broker uses software, but what the software decides, what a person still decides, and how you can check both. This checklist gives logistics and supply chain teams twenty questions to ask any AI freight broker, what a good answer looks like, and how Throughline answers each one.

No platform fee. No login required to estimate a lane. Nothing is booked without approval.

Licensed freight broker · MC-1819296 · USDOT 4573052 · $75,000 BMC-84 bond(855) 916-5957

For an accurate quote

Have these ready

  • One real lane you ship often, with origin and destination ZIPs
  • Equipment, pickup date, weight and commodity
  • The quote your current broker gave you, to compare
  • The two or three questions above that matter most to your team
Start my quote

Licensing and liability

Start with the basics, because they rule out the most risk in the least time. A good answer is specific and checkable on the spot.

  • 1. What is your MC number and USDOT number? Look them up on the FMCSA SAFER system and confirm active property broker authority.
  • 2. Do you hold a BMC-84 bond or BMC-85 trust? Brokers must have one; ask which.
  • 3. Are you the broker or the carrier on my load? An AI freight broker arranges transportation; it should never appear as the motor carrier of record unless it actually operates trucks.
  • 4. Do you double broker or re-broker loads? The answer should be no, and the carrier on the rate confirmation should be the one that hauls the freight.

Pricing and quote transparency

Instant quotes are the most visible AI feature and the easiest to oversell. Ask what sits behind the number.

  • 5. Is the instant number an estimate or a firm quote, and how long is a firm quote valid?
  • 6. Does the quote show how confident it is, or only a single figure?
  • 7. What happens on a lane with little recent data — does the tool guess, or does a person price it?
  • 8. Are accessorials such as detention, lumper, tarps or driver assist listed separately, or folded into one all-in number?
  • 9. Can I price my whole lane list at once, and see which lanes are likely to be hard to cover?

Carrier vetting and fraud

Freight fraud and identity theft are the reason many shippers are wary of new brokers. Software can make vetting more consistent; it should never make it optional.

  • 10. What do you check on every carrier before the rate confirmation — authority, identity, insurance, safety rating, fraud signals?
  • 11. What are your minimum cargo and auto liability insurance limits?
  • 12. What happens when a check cannot be confirmed — does the load go through, or to a person?
  • 13. Who approves the carrier, and can I hold every booking for my own approval?

Human oversight

An AI-operated broker is only as good as the line it draws between what the software does alone and what a person signs off.

  • 14. Which decisions does a person make? Carrier approval, exceptions and unusual freight are the minimum.
  • 15. If I call, who answers, and can I reach a person during the call?
  • 16. Is every check, approval and status change logged, so a problem load can be reconstructed afterward?

Tracking, paperwork and fit

Finally, check that the day-to-day matches how your team works.

  • 17. How will I hear about pickup, delays and delivery without making a check call?
  • 18. Can my receiver track the load without creating an account?
  • 19. Can my team keep tendering by email, or do we have to learn a new portal first?
  • 20. How do the invoice, POD and BOL arrive, and is there any platform fee?

How Throughline answers

Throughline Systems LLC holds FMCSA property broker authority and a BMC-84 bond; the MC and USDOT numbers are printed on every page. The instant result is an estimate with a low-to-high spread and a confidence level, and a firm quote follows when you add the shipment details. A firm quote stays good for 3 days. After that we refresh it, and live truck options can change the price. Lanes without enough recent data, and all hazmat freight, are priced by a person. Known accessorials are separate lines.

Before any rate con goes out, we check active FMCSA authority and carrier identity, require at least $100,000 cargo and $750,000 auto liability insurance, match the carrier's phone to its FMCSA record, and screen against a library of known fraud patterns. Anything that can't be confirmed goes to a person — it doesn't go through. Carriers with an Unsatisfactory FMCSA safety rating or an active out-of-service order are never dispatched, and a Conditional rating needs a manager’s sign-off.

A person approves every carrier. “Hold for me” is the default: no carrier is booked on your load without your OK. Every check, approval and status change is logged on the load. Call (855) 916-5957 and Cole, Throughline’s AI agent, answers and can transfer you to a person at any point.

Milestone updates arrive at booking, pickup, delays and delivery, each with a no-login tracking link for your receiver. Tenders and quote requests can come in by email. When the POD is verified, your invoice arrives as one PDF with the POD and BOL attached. There is no platform fee to quote, track or use the shipper portal.

Start with a lane estimate, then confirm the shipment details.

Test us on one real lane
What changes when we run your truckload

Less chasing. Fewer surprises.

The same five commitments on every load, starting with the one that matters most here.

The carrier on the rate con is the carrier that shows up.

Before any rate con goes out we check active authority, verify identity, require at least $100,000 cargo and $750,000 auto liability, and flag “paper” carriers. Carriers with an Unsatisfactory FMCSA safety rating or an active out-of-service order are never dispatched, and a Conditional rating needs a manager’s sign-off. Bank-detail changes wait 48 hours.

  • Checked before the rate con
  • 48-hour hold on bank changes

If your load is at risk, you hear first — with choices.

When a truck isn’t confirmed as pickup nears, we email up to three options you can click: approve a revised rate, move pickup a day, or switch to a team truck. If a booked carrier misses pickup or drops the load, we start re-sourcing.

  • One-click choices by email
  • Re-sourcing on a no-show or fall-off

Stop asking where the truck is.

You hear when the carrier is booked, at pickup with the driver’s name and mobile, if it’s running late, at delivery, and when the POD is on file. Updates carry a no-login tracking link you can forward to your receiver, and a brief of your freight lands every Monday.

  • Driver name and mobile at pickup
  • No-login link for your receiver

Keep emailing your loads. We’ll take it from there.

Send tenders, quote requests or lane spreadsheets the way you do today. They become priced quotes and loads, and every tender gets a clear accept or decline.

  • No new portal to learn first
  • Clear accept / decline on tenders

Invoice and POD in one file.

When the POD is verified, your invoice arrives as one PDF with the POD and BOL attached. Your AP team gets the paperwork with the bill instead of asking for it.

  • Invoice + POD + BOL
  • Raised on delivery

“Hold for me” is the default: no carrier is booked on your load without your OK. A firm quote stays good for 3 days. After that we refresh it, and live truck options can change the price.

Straight answers

Questions shippers ask

Talk to a person
01

How do I evaluate an AI freight broker?

+

Check five things: verifiable FMCSA broker authority and a bond, a quote that shows its confidence and lists accessorials separately, carrier vetting before every rate confirmation, a person who approves carriers and owns exceptions, and tracking and paperwork that arrive without chasing. Then test the broker on one real lane before moving volume.

02

What questions should I ask an AI freight broker?

+

Ask for the MC and USDOT numbers, whether the instant number is an estimate or a firm quote, what is checked on each carrier before the rate confirmation, what happens when a check fails, which decisions a person makes, and how you will hear about pickup, delays and delivery.

03

How can I verify that an AI freight broker is licensed?

+

Search the broker’s MC or USDOT number on the FMCSA SAFER system and confirm active property broker authority, then ask for proof of its BMC-84 bond or BMC-85 trust. Throughline prints its MC and USDOT numbers on every page.

04

What is a red flag when choosing an AI freight broker?

+

A broker that cannot say which decisions a person makes, that books carriers without vetting them first, that shows one all-in number with no confidence or accessorial detail, or whose authority you cannot verify on FMCSA SAFER.

05

Should a person still approve the carrier if the broker uses AI?

+

Yes. Software can run the same checks on every carrier, but carrier approval carries real fraud and cargo risk. At Throughline a person approves every carrier before the rate confirmation is sent, and you can hold every booking for your own approval.

06

How do I choose a freight broker for full truckload freight?

+

Pick for the lanes and freight you actually ship. Confirm active FMCSA broker authority and a bond, ask which equipment the broker covers on your lanes, how it vets each carrier before the rate confirmation, what happens when a carrier rejects a tender, how you hear about pickup and delays, and whether the price is all-in or linehaul plus fuel. Then test one real lane.

07

How do I test an AI freight broker before switching volume?

+

Price one lane you know well and compare the estimate, its spread and its confidence with the quote you have. Then tender a single load and watch the carrier vetting, updates and paperwork from booking to the invoice.

Plan the shipment before you automate it

Give the freight team clear equipment, handling and delivery requirements. These guides help you prepare a request AI can organize and a person can review.

A person approves the carrier

Price one real lane. No login.

Get my quote
Get my quoteCreate account