Step 1: record it at delivery
The receiver should inspect the freight before the driver leaves, write the damage or shortage on the delivery receipt in specific words (for example, “4 cartons crushed, pallet 3 leaning, product exposed”), and take photos of the trailer, the freight and the seal before anything is moved. A note like “subject to inspection” is weak evidence because it does not say what was wrong.
In most cases, accept the good freight and note the damaged part rather than refusing the whole load. Refused freight still has to go somewhere, and the costs of returning or storing it usually make the claim bigger and slower. Refusing makes sense only when the shipment cannot be used at all.
Step 2: put the claim in writing
Federal claim rules for interstate motor carriers (49 CFR part 370) treat a claim as filed when the carrier receives a written communication that identifies the shipment, asserts that the carrier is liable, and asks for a specified or determinable amount of money. A phone call or a note on the POD alone is not a filed claim.
Send the claim with the documents that prove what was shipped, what arrived and what it was worth:
- The bill of lading, with the piece count and the seal number if there was one
- The delivery receipt or POD showing the exceptions noted at delivery
- Photos of the damage, the trailer and the load as it arrived
- A commercial invoice or other proof of the value of the damaged goods
- A repair estimate, or a statement that the goods are a total loss and what happened to them
- The amount you are claiming and how it was calculated
Step 3: know the deadlines
Under the Carmack Amendment (49 U.S.C. 14706) a carrier may not give you less than nine months to file a claim, and the contract or bill of lading can set the exact window. Concealed damage, found only after the freight is unpacked, should be reported to the carrier within days, not months, because the longer the gap the harder it is to show the damage happened in transit.
Once a claim is filed, the same federal rules require the carrier to acknowledge it in writing within 30 days and to pay, decline or make a firm compromise offer within 120 days. If it cannot, it must tell you the status, and why, at least every 60 days after that.
Keep the damaged goods until the carrier or its insurer has had a chance to inspect them or has agreed in writing to their disposal. Throwing freight away early is one of the most common reasons a claim is reduced or denied.
How Throughline handles a damage claim
When a delivery POD comes back with an exception, Throughline treats it as a problem to resolve, not a load to bill. The claim is opened against the load with the POD, the carrier and the details on file, and the invoice for that load waits for a person to review it. Software sorts and recommends; a person makes the call on how the claim is pursued, and no money moves on a recommendation alone.
Liability for cargo sits with the motor carrier under Carmack, and Throughline does not take it on as broker. Its job is to get the claim to the carrier and its cargo insurer with the evidence attached, follow it to an answer, and keep you informed. Before any rate con goes out, we check active FMCSA authority and carrier identity, require at least $100,000 cargo and $750,000 auto liability insurance, match the carrier's phone to its FMCSA record, and screen against a library of known fraud patterns. Anything that can't be confirmed goes to a person — it doesn't go through.
The cheapest claim is the one that never happens, which is why the commodity, packaging, tarp and securement requirements you give with the quote travel to the carrier with the load, and why the carrier’s cargo insurance is checked before the rate confirmation.