Five protections, and what each one does
Shippers often hear these terms used as if they were interchangeable. They are not:
- Broker bond or trust (BMC-84 or BMC-85): the financial security every property broker must have in place to be registered. It can pay shippers or motor carriers if the broker fails to carry out its contracts. It is not a fund for damaged freight.
- Carrier auto liability: covers injury and property damage to the public from operating the truck. Federal minimums apply, and they rise for many hazardous materials. It does not pay for the freight on the trailer.
- Carrier cargo insurance: the policy most cargo claims actually land on. For general freight, FMCSA dropped its cargo filing requirement in 2011, so the limit you can rely on usually comes from contract terms and the carrier’s policy, not a federal minimum.
- Contingent cargo insurance: a policy some brokers buy for themselves. It may respond in narrow cases, such as when a carrier’s policy does not pay. Terms vary widely, and it is written to protect the broker, so do not treat it as coverage for you.
- Your own cargo policy: coverage you buy for your goods. It is the one protection written around your freight and your values rather than someone else’s risk.
Who pays when freight is lost or damaged
Interstate truck cargo claims usually run under the Carmack Amendment, 49 U.S.C. 14706, which makes the carrier liable for the actual loss or injury to the property. A carrier can limit that liability to a value declared by the shipper or agreed between the parties, if the limit is reasonable and the contract supports it. So the bill of lading and any released value on it matter as much as the policy behind them.
A broker that only arranges transportation is generally not the Carmack carrier. Courts can reach a different answer when a company presents itself as the carrier or takes on that responsibility by contract, which is one more reason to read who the paperwork names. Federal law bars a carrier from giving you less than 9 months to file a claim or less than 2 years to sue after a written denial, though your contract can set terms above those floors. Note damage on the delivery receipt and file in writing as soon as you can.
Why a certificate alone is not enough
A certificate of insurance is a snapshot. It shows limits and dates on the day it was issued, and it does not list every exclusion. Before a valuable load moves, look at four things:
- Limit against value: a load worth more than the cargo limit leaves a gap, even if the claim is paid in full
- Exclusions: policies differ on theft, reefer breakdown, certain commodities and unattended vehicles
- Name and dates: the named insured should match the carrier hauling the load, and coverage should run through delivery
- Source: a certificate sent from the insurer or agent is stronger than one that arrives through the carrier alone
What to decide before you tender
Add up what a total loss would cost you at the value you can prove, usually invoice value. If that is above the cargo limit a typical carrier holds, you have three choices: state the required coverage so the load is priced and placed against it, buy your own policy for the shipment, or accept the gap on purpose. Make that decision before pickup. After a loss, the only coverage that counts is the coverage already in place.
How this works at Throughline
Throughline is a licensed property broker with a BMC-84 surety bond at the federal requirement. We arrange transportation and are never the motor carrier of record. We do not insure cargo, and the bond is not cargo insurance. Cargo claims run against the carrier, and we give you the carrier’s identity, insurance and documents and reasonably assist with the claim.
Before any rate con goes out, we check active FMCSA authority and carrier identity, require at least $100,000 cargo and $750,000 auto liability insurance, match the carrier's phone to its FMCSA record, and screen against a library of known fraud patterns. Anything that can't be confirmed goes to a person — it doesn't go through.
Enter the declared cargo value and coverage requirements before requesting a quote. Throughline checks carrier cargo coverage against a baseline minimum of $100,000; that carrier policy is not a shipper-owned insurance policy. Entering a higher value does not establish that additional insurance has been placed. Confirm the applicable limits, exclusions, deductibles and any additional arrangement in writing before pickup. Hazmat insurance and acceptance require separate review.